个人资料
正文

2025.3.3 卡尼回击哈珀质疑其经济能力的信件

(2026-01-31 06:15:04) 下一个

“修正主义历史”:卡尼回击哈珀质疑其经济能力的信件

https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/article/revisionist-history-carney-hits-back-at-harper-over-letter-challenging-the-liberal-leadership-frontrunners-economic-chops/

作者:Rachel Aiello 2025年3月3日

这张资料照片显示,2012年1月26日,时任加拿大央行行长马克·卡尼在达沃斯世界经济论坛上,加拿大总理斯蒂芬·哈珀与国际商界领袖举行会议。(加拿大通讯社/Adrian Wyld)

自由党领袖候选人马克·卡尼回击了前保守党总理斯蒂芬·哈珀,后者指责卡尼不正当地将经济功劳揽在自己身上。

针对哈珀写给保守党成员的一封信(这封信被当作筹款宣传材料发出),卡尼的竞选团队指责哈珀受命“拯救皮埃尔·波利耶夫,避免其支持率出现历史性暴跌”。

“但无论如何篡改历史,都无法抹杀卡尼先生在经济领导方面的卓越成就,”他的竞选团队在一份声明中表示。

卡尼的团队还重申了哈珀曾主动联系他担任财政部长的说法,并指出这位前总理本可以选择波利耶夫,但他并没有这样做。

该声明还提及了包括哈珀在内的几位保守党知名人士对卡尼担任加拿大央行行长期间工作的评价。

卡尼竞选团队表示:“加拿大人都知道,皮埃尔·波利耶夫及其团队既没有保护加拿大经济的经验,也没有相应的计划,更没有能力在国家危机中对抗唐纳德·特朗普。卡尼先生已准备好领导加拿大,并打造七国集团中最强大的经济体。”

哈珀称卡尼将弗莱厄蒂的“艰难决策”归功于自己

哈珀于2008年任命卡尼为加拿大央行行长。周一,哈珀公开抨击这位前央行行长夸大了自己在带领加拿大度过全球金融危机中所起的作用。

在一封致保守党的筹款信中,哈珀质疑了卡尼的经济政绩,并指出鉴于美国总统唐纳德·特朗普即将加征关税,加拿大正面临巨大的经济风险。

哈珀写道:“我越来越难以置信地听到马克·卡尼试图将当年与他几乎无关的事情归功于自己。”

“他这样做是以牺牲已故的吉姆·弗莱厄蒂(Jim Flaherty)的利益为代价的,弗莱厄蒂是加拿大历史上最伟大的财政部长之一,可惜他已不在人世,无法为自己的政绩辩护。但我要明确指出:2008-2009年全球金融危机期间的艰难决策都是吉姆做出的。”

哈珀接着说,卡尼作为自由党经济顾问的经验与碳税和巨额赤字密切相关,并称这位领导人候选人“在所有重大问题上都犯了错误”。

“卡尼想把我们保守党的政绩据为己有的真正原因是,他不敢谈论他真正的‘经验’,”哈珀说。

弗莱厄蒂的前幕僚也发表了看法

一位弗莱厄蒂的前幕僚周一接受CTV新闻采访时表示,虽然他同意他的前老板主导了诸如550亿加元赤字等政治和财政决策,但卡尼在货币政策方面的作用也不容忽视。

“卡尼和弗莱厄蒂私交甚笃,这在幕后是无法言说的。他们彼此欣赏,经常交流,合作也很愉快,”奇泽姆·波蒂埃说道。

波蒂埃曾在博利耶夫当选总理的竞选中为一位竞争对手的竞选活动效力,如今他已不再是联邦保守党成员。他形容卡尼是当时财政部长哈珀的“智囊团”。

“在卡尼进入加拿大政坛之前,人们普遍认为哈珀、弗莱厄蒂和卡尼带领我们度过了危机,并帮助我们走上了复苏之路,”他说道。他还指出,他们的工作关系可以追溯到全球金融危机之前,当时卡尼还是财政部的一位高级官员。

自由党正在缩小民调差距

卡尼和哈珀都称即将到来的联邦选举是他们一生中最重要的一次投票。

自总理贾斯汀·特鲁多辞职、继任者竞选拉开帷幕以来,自由党的支持率大幅上升,显著缩小了与保守党的差距。

几个月来,博利耶夫领导的保守党一直保持着约20个百分点的民调优势。但截至上周,加拿大电视台(CTV News)的民调专家尼克·纳诺斯表示,如果举行大选,结果将“难分伯仲”,保守党的支持率为37%,自由党为33%。

纳诺斯当时表示,这些数字表明,一些加拿大人质疑,为什么保守党将攻击重点放在卡尼身上,而不是花更多时间讨论特朗普和关税问题。

 

“这不再是一场变革之选。实际上,这将是一场谁能更好地应对唐纳德·特朗普,以及加拿大人更信任谁的选举。”

“我们需要在与美国的关系上取得某种积极的进展。所以,我认为变革已成定局,将成为此次投票议题,”纳诺斯说道。

“我们可能会发现,加拿大人投票并非出于对政党的喜爱,也并非出于对潜在领导人的欣赏,而是出于对摆在他们面前的选择的考量,变得非常功利。”

自由党将于周日选举下一任党魁。尽管一些选民在党内身份验证过程中遇到了问题,但该党发言人帕克·伦德表示,系统运行正常,确保投票安全,并且有一个团队正在处理更复杂的案例。

投票已于上周开始。截至目前,在40万名有资格投票的自由党注册选民中,已有10万人通过身份验证,其中7.8万人已完成投票。

(本文部分内容来自CTV新闻记者斯蒂芬妮·哈的报道)

'Revisionist history’: Carney hits back at Harper over letter challenging the Liberal leadership frontrunner’s economic chops

https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/article/revisionist-history-carney-hits-back-at-harper-over-letter-challenging-the-liberal-leadership-frontrunners-economic-chops/

By  Rachel Aiello   

In this file photo, then-Bank of Canada Governor Mark Carney looks on as Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper opens a meeting with international business leaders at the World Economic Forum in Davos, January 26, 2012. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld (The Canadian Press)

Liberal leadership frontrunner Mark Carney is hitting back at former Conservative prime minister Stephen Harper for accusing the Liberal leadership frontrunner of taking undue economic credit.

Responding to a letter Harper penned to Conservative party members – and sent out as a fundraising blast – Carney’s campaign accused Harper of being called on “to save Pierre Poilievre from a historic drop in support.”

“But no amount of revisionist history can take away from Mr. Carney’s proven record of economic leadership,” his campaign said in a statement.

Carney’s team also doubled down on the assertion that Harper approached him to serve as finance minister, in noting that the former prime minister could have picked Poilievre, but didn’t.

The statement also included a handful of references to comments made by prominent Conservatives, including Harper, of the job Carney did as Canada’s central banker.

“Canadians know that Pierre Poilievre and his team bring no experience or plan to protect our economy, and no ability to stand up to Donald Trump in a national crisis. Mr. Carney is ready to lead Canada and to build the strongest economy in the G7,” Carney’s campaign said.

Harper says Carney taking credit for Flaherty ‘hard calls’

Harper – who appointed Carney to run the Bank of Canada back in 2008 – spoke out Monday, blasting the former central banker for overstating his role in steering the country through the global financial crisis.

In a fundraising letter sent to Conservatives, Harper questioned Carney’s economic record, in the context of the massive economic danger Canada is facing in light of U.S. President Donald Trump’s impending tariffs.

“I have listened, with increasing disbelief, to Mark Carney’s attempts to take credit for things he had little or nothing to do with back then,” Harper writes.

“He has been doing this at the expense of the late Jim Flaherty, among the greatest finance ministers in Canada’s history, who sadly is not here to defend his record. But let me be very clear: the hard calls during the 2008-2009 global financial crisis were made by Jim.”

Harper went on to say Carney’s experience as a Liberal economic advisor is tied to the carbon tax and sizeable deficits, calling the leadership contender “wrong on all the big issues.”

“The real reason Carney wants to claim our Conservative record for himself is that he dare not speak of his actual ‘experience,’” Harper said.

Former Flaherty staffer weighs in

One former Flaherty staffer, speaking to CTV News on Monday, said while he agrees his former boss led the political and fiscal decisions such as running a $55 billion deficit, Carney’s role on the monetary side shouldn’t be minimized.

“Behind the scenes and intangible is that Carney and Flaherty were close. They liked each other. They talked a lot, and they worked well together,” said Chisholm Pothier.

Pothier – who worked on a rival candidates’ leadership campaign during the race that elected Poilievre and is no longer a federal Conservative member – described Carney as “a sounding board” for the then-finance minister.

“Up until Carney entered the political scene in Canada, it was generally a given that Harper, Flaherty, and Carney got us through the crisis and helped and set us on the path to recovery,” he said, noting their working relationship predated the global financial crisis, to when Carney was a senior bureaucrat at the finance department.

Liberals closing polling gap

Both Carney and Harper have called the coming federal election the most consequential vote of their lifetimes.

Since Prime Minister Justin Trudeau resigned and the race to replace him kicked off, the Liberals have seen a sizeable uptick in support, considerably narrowing the Conservatives’ lead.

For months, Poilievre’s Conservatives had been enjoying around a 20-point polling advantage but as of last week, CTV News’ pollster Nik Nanos said that if an election was called, it would be “a coin toss,” with the Conservatives sitting at 37 per cent support, and the Liberals at 33 per cent.

Nanos said at the time that the numbers indicate some Canadians are questioning why Consevatives are focusing their attacks on Carney, rather than spending more time talking about Trump and tariffs.

“It’s not going to be a change election anymore. It’s actually going to be who can best manage Donald Trump, and who do Canadians trust to move forward in some sort of positive way in the relationship with the United States. So, I think change is out the door as the ballot question,” Nanos said.

“We may find that Canadians don’t vote for a party that they like. They don’t vote for potentially a leader that they like, but that Canadians as voters become very mercenary, looking at the choices that are before them.”

Liberals will elect their next leader on Sunday. While some voters have run into issues with the party’s verification processes, party spokesperson Parker Lund said the system is working as it should to ensure a secure vote, and that there’s a team working to troubleshoot more complex cases.

Voting opened last week. So far, of the 400,000 registered Liberals eligible to cast a ballot, 100,000 people have been verified, and of those 78,000 have cast a ballot so far.

With files from CTV News’ Stephanie Ha

[ 打印 ]
评论
目前还没有任何评论
登录后才可评论.